Comments on: Fighting For Something That Was Never There To Begin With http://commonsenseworld.com/2007/03/fighting-for-something-that-was-never-there-to-begin-with/ Bringing Sanity Back To The World Fri, 18 May 2012 21:30:40 +0000 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.5.1 By: Chandira http://commonsenseworld.com/2007/03/fighting-for-something-that-was-never-there-to-begin-with/#comment-1503 Chandira Thu, 05 Apr 2007 17:47:00 +0000 http://annafiltest.wordpress.com/2007/03/20/fighting-for-something-that-was-never-there-to-begin-with/#comment-1503 Sometimes I think the politicians in charge have about as much political knowledge of the situation in Iraq as I do! Which is not a lot... <br/><br/>What is it going to take to get them to stop the insanity? Because it is insanity. If you apply the facts of how our govt has acted here, to any other situation, it would look <i>completely crazy.</i> Sometimes I think the politicians in charge have about as much political knowledge of the situation in Iraq as I do! Which is not a lot…

What is it going to take to get them to stop the insanity? Because it is insanity. If you apply the facts of how our govt has acted here, to any other situation, it would look completely crazy.

]]> By: The Randomness http://commonsenseworld.com/2007/03/fighting-for-something-that-was-never-there-to-begin-with/#comment-1502 The Randomness Sat, 31 Mar 2007 20:20:00 +0000 http://annafiltest.wordpress.com/2007/03/20/fighting-for-something-that-was-never-there-to-begin-with/#comment-1502 ***need an American solution ***need an American solution

]]> By: The Randomness http://commonsenseworld.com/2007/03/fighting-for-something-that-was-never-there-to-begin-with/#comment-1501 The Randomness Sat, 31 Mar 2007 20:19:00 +0000 http://annafiltest.wordpress.com/2007/03/20/fighting-for-something-that-was-never-there-to-begin-with/#comment-1501 Excellent writing! It annoys me that people who have no inkling on ethnic conflict (and who play up on it) are supposed to be the ones who will bring peace about. America needs to recognise that every problem does not have an American solution. The arrogance is just too much. Excellent writing! It annoys me that people who have no inkling on ethnic conflict (and who play up on it) are supposed to be the ones who will bring peace about. America needs to recognise that every problem does not have an American solution. The arrogance is just too much.

]]> By: Elle Rayne http://commonsenseworld.com/2007/03/fighting-for-something-that-was-never-there-to-begin-with/#comment-1500 Elle Rayne Tue, 27 Mar 2007 07:36:00 +0000 http://annafiltest.wordpress.com/2007/03/20/fighting-for-something-that-was-never-there-to-begin-with/#comment-1500 "Stopping a war is actually pretty easy when you have a defined enemy. You call a formal truce, arrange a peace treaty meeting, make agreements, and cease armed hostility. It can't be done overnight, but it certainly can be done.<br/>When faced with an amorphous enemy or one who has no desire to make peace with you, you have no alternative but to fight until one side can fight no longer. Or until one side can be convinced to fight no longer."<br/><br/>Excellent point. I am so sad and disgusted that this war is still dragging on, with little hope of it ending well. “Stopping a war is actually pretty easy when you have a defined enemy. You call a formal truce, arrange a peace treaty meeting, make agreements, and cease armed hostility. It can’t be done overnight, but it certainly can be done.
When faced with an amorphous enemy or one who has no desire to make peace with you, you have no alternative but to fight until one side can fight no longer. Or until one side can be convinced to fight no longer.”

Excellent point. I am so sad and disgusted that this war is still dragging on, with little hope of it ending well.

]]> By: Muhammad http://commonsenseworld.com/2007/03/fighting-for-something-that-was-never-there-to-begin-with/#comment-1499 Muhammad Thu, 22 Mar 2007 12:31:00 +0000 http://annafiltest.wordpress.com/2007/03/20/fighting-for-something-that-was-never-there-to-begin-with/#comment-1499 What I find sad is Neo-con's total disregard for public opinion that the War is bullshit. A couple of months more or even years is not going to stablisie the region by the US asserting its presence in the region. The arab countries surrounding Iraq also have an effect on this situation and sentiment for the US isn't exactly on a good footing in the Arab world.<br/><br/>Let's hope, someone with some sense can put an end to it, sooner rather than later. What I find sad is Neo-con’s total disregard for public opinion that the War is bullshit. A couple of months more or even years is not going to stablisie the region by the US asserting its presence in the region. The arab countries surrounding Iraq also have an effect on this situation and sentiment for the US isn’t exactly on a good footing in the Arab world.

Let’s hope, someone with some sense can put an end to it, sooner rather than later.

]]> By: Political Realm http://commonsenseworld.com/2007/03/fighting-for-something-that-was-never-there-to-begin-with/#comment-1498 Political Realm Tue, 20 Mar 2007 14:11:00 +0000 http://annafiltest.wordpress.com/2007/03/20/fighting-for-something-that-was-never-there-to-begin-with/#comment-1498 While I do think that partition should be a considered option, there are certainly drawbacks. Iraq is not perfectly divided upon ethnic lines. There will always be minority populations within each region and those people will be target by militias, whether Sunni or Shia, just as they are today. And while its certainly possible that a political peace could be reached between the people, it seems unlikely that they are willing to work together or trust each other. <br/>The major problem, however, is probably oil, which is largerly in the SE part of the country. It would be nearly impossible for the three groups to reach an agreement that would spread the wealth. <br/><br/>Of course, maybe and hopefully it could work. The Kurds have established control over the Northern part of the country already--an area where I believe the military had good success rooting out terrorists. <br/><br/>Just a sad situation all around. <br/><br/>Time had a good article about it a while back: http://www.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,1555130,00.html While I do think that partition should be a considered option, there are certainly drawbacks. Iraq is not perfectly divided upon ethnic lines. There will always be minority populations within each region and those people will be target by militias, whether Sunni or Shia, just as they are today. And while its certainly possible that a political peace could be reached between the people, it seems unlikely that they are willing to work together or trust each other.
The major problem, however, is probably oil, which is largerly in the SE part of the country. It would be nearly impossible for the three groups to reach an agreement that would spread the wealth.

Of course, maybe and hopefully it could work. The Kurds have established control over the Northern part of the country already–an area where I believe the military had good success rooting out terrorists.

Just a sad situation all around.

Time had a good article about it a while back: http://www.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,1555130,00.html

]]>